Pizza restaurants

Tony's Cafe - Taneytown

4.2 275 reviews 12:00 PM - 08:00 PM 520 E Baltimore St, Taneytown, MD 21787, United States

Discover this place

Tony's Cafe is a pizza restaurant located in Taneytown, Maryland, offering a variety of classic and hearty dishes. The menu features Italian-inspired options such as New York style pizza, meat pizza, and a cheese oregano pie, alongside American comfort foods like chicken pot pie and cheesesteak subs. The cafe provides a spacious and relaxed dining atmosphere with separate dining and bar areas, accommodating both casual meals and social gatherings. Its setting reflects a neighborhood bar vibe, creating a welcoming space for regular patrons and newcomers alike. The service is attentive without being intrusive, supporting a comfortable dining experience. The inclusion of traditional Italian seasonings like garlic powder and oregano complements the flavors and adds authenticity to the dishes served. Overall, Tony's Cafe stands out as a local spot combining pizza and Italian-American fare with a laid-back yet clean environment, capturing the essence of a community-focused eatery in Taneytown.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great dessert
Sports

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Tony's Cafe - Taneytown before visiting.

Reviews for Tony's Cafe - Taneytown

4.2

275 reviews

100%

38%

16%

Review highlights

Based on 275 reviews

Tony's Cafe in Taneytown is frequently praised for its warm, neighborhood bar atmosphere combined with a spacious and clean dining environment. Customers consistently highlight the attentive and friendly service, noting staff members who strike a balance between being helpful and unobtrusive. The menu offers a variety of Italian and American comfort foods, with particular acclaim for items like pizza, stromboli, calamari, and unique appetizers such as crab fondue. Food quality is commonly described as flavorful and generously portioned, appealing to both locals and visitors. The casual, relaxed setting makes it an inviting spot for regulars and newcomers alike, contributing to a strong sense of community. Overall, Tony’s Cafe is recognized for delivering consistently satisfying meals paired with hospitable service in a comfortable and welcoming atmosphere.

Bruce Culver

Jul 27, 2025

We love Tony's. It is a typical neighborhood bar. If you go there regularly, you'll get to know the crew and the waitresses... And although they are all great, Rachel is our favorite!

Lisa Boorom

Jul 18, 2025

We stopped into Tony's, after looking at some homes in Taneytown. It was such a nice place. The waitress was very friendly. The food was delicious. We ordered the Crab Fondue as an appetizer, and it was so good. There were huge pieces of crab in it. I had a stromboli for one, and it was huge. If we move to Taneytown, we will definitely go back to Tony's Cafe.

Mark Bortle

Jul 14, 2025

The food is fantastic, the waitresses were friendly. Would hands down recommend to anyone looking for some great Italian food in taneytown.

SMarie

May 26, 2025

Calamari was hot and crispy, salad with chicken was amazing. Hamburger sliders arrived hot, great rolls! Cheeseburger sub, again, great flavor. Laid back atmosphere, definitely will be back. Server was attentive without being intrusive.

Laura West

May 03, 2025

We really enjoyed our New York style pizza! We loved how they had garlic powder, oregano shakers along with cheese, salt and pepper. The desserts looked delicious, but we were full with our pizza. We will definitely be back soon. The dining area as well as the bar area are spacious with plenty of seating. Nice, relaxed, clean atmosphere. Our server was extremely accommodating and eager to meet our needs. The menu stretches way beyond the pizza menu, so be sure to check it all out.

D.B. Frank

Apr 22, 2025

In the strip mall where this was located so walked over. Sports bar on Sunday, so the bar crowd was loud, of course. Staff was pleasant. Had the NY pizza, which was delicious. Certainly not going to drive there, but would stop if in the mall again.

olivia rand

Apr 18, 2025

Really happy with the restaurant everyone is nice and the pizza and boneless wings are amazing!